If I understand this BTC mechanism properly (and I've never used it, so disclaimer there), once the consumer says "yes" there's no going back as far as they're concerned. Since the merchant is going to always say "yes" right away, that means that the only way to approximate the level of consumer protection that credit cards offer using this protocol is if the consumer makes a habit of waiting up to 6 months to release funds to the merchant. Which is something I wouldn't blame merchants for not being willing to accept such a situation. Defaulting to "180 days, same as cash" sounds like a terrible business practice to me.