The surgeons who take these patients may end up having terrible stats, but be the most skilled if only because their mortality rate is not pushing 100%.
Comparing this statistic the way people compare gas mileage is a disincentive for these surgeons to operate on patients that need help, but are high risk.
Fun fact: Dr. Oz is in there and it even looks like he might be one of the better performing surgeons too. Another fun fact: it can be hard to draw inferences about individual providers this way; check out just how wide some of the the 95% CIs for the RAMRs are, and a lot hinges on how good your risk adjustment model is (details on pg 13).
Early next year, CMS will post healthcare quality metrics that it's collected from providers who bill to CMS. In 2015, hospitals will start getting reimbursed based on quality, which is a step in the right direction, however, it is chocked with problems (i.e. treating the best patients will advantage a hospital)