http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2007-07-22/the-high-cost...
The end result is that many of these counties have extremely large power and water production capabilities built up and no one to sell to. The datacenters are attractive because they will actually buy these utilities at much higher capacities than the community would otherwise. This is worth much more than any small number of jobs created.
Seriosuly though, you're right, if nobody offered subsidies, they would all be on a level playing field and market forces would win out. However, it only takes one to break rank and the free market is gone.
The problem is not incentivizing just your old textile/paper-processing county, it's competing with all of the other ones. So at the end of the day hopefully everyone's done their homework and the community is still making more money than it was before.
Again, I'm not sure what the point here is as US States are not much different from countries in a race to the bottom, other than sooner or later you hit bottom. I mainly just found it amusing as it was a huge deal for Lenoir and now here it is on the front page of HN!
Disclaimer: Googler, commenting as private person, not as company rep, etc.
Consider: big companies have expert negotiators. Cities have volunteers.
I think at least some Google DC's have a small office block on site possibly for adwords employees.
I see eight by the guardhouse, one occupied; a further 20 by one data centre, 8 occupied; and a final 23 near another data centre, 6 occupied. Totals: 53 spaces, 15 occupied.
I don't see any bicycle parking or signs of indoor or underground car parks, and there are no sidewalks or bus stops nearby that I can see. This is the middle of the day - I doubt the night shift is any busier.
My money's on 15-30 employees on the day shift, plus a night shift for an additional 4-8 employees depending on shift patterns. So 19-39 total employees. If I'm wrong, I'd love to know how those employees are getting to work :)