If this is true, this is disempowering to Google for 2 reasons:
1. Many potential superstars simply never get the opportunity to go to a "top-tier school".
2. In applicability to real world requirements, the difference between a "top-tier school" and a second level school is negligible. That is, if there was a scale of what was important from 1 to 100, with 100 as a total super star, then a top-tier school would make you a 10 instead of a 9. Big deal.