One red flag in this case is that the CFO referred to PwC, a major accounting firm that her former company paid for some advice, as a reason why everything was OK. This amounts to "trust me" because you have no access to the terms under which PwC was retained by the other company and no idea who actually examined the options accounting or under what circumstances. Shady dealing is often obscured by appeals to a higher power.
If you run into this in your own company you should be suspicious and try to get the company to hire an independent expert to review the situation, which is exactly what Ben did. For an expert to be truly independent they need to be retained by someone outside the group under suspicion.
Suspicion is not a bad thing as long as you deal with it promptly. Dealing with it clarifies the situation and removes the suspicion, one way or another.