The answer is 'it depends'. There are a variety of processes and materials that are called 3D printing. For plastic fused deposition modeling (like the Makerbot), objects can be comparable to say, injection molded parts, which is a more common plastic production method. For metal, selective laser sintering is the most common method, and the parts it produces have different (and probably inferior in most cases) properties than cast/forged/machined parts. There's way too much variety on either side of the coin to say which is more fragile.