Its obviously not a 'nightmare' in that people will still use it gladly but its not great and has been getting worse for some time. Big problems it suffers from include:
* filling your screen by default with a plethora of things that an average user won't use and is vaguely terrified to touch because they aren't sure what they will do.
* lack of logical ordering of things. the structure behind screen real estate areas is poor.
a good case is the drop down below the Google logo to top left that says 'gmail' - does anyone use this? maybe a tiny percentage. would you even know what menu options might be hiding underneath a drop down that says 'gmail'? didn't think so.