I just quickly glanced at some figures, like "Have they earned it?", and it seemed wrong.
The author says the total return for say Barclay was 12.61%.
bc -l running in a terminal disagree
Taking 100 as the base value to ease our math:
100x1.112x1.0825x0.9452x1.1088=126.156497322240000
That's a 26% something cumulative return in 4 years. What is this 12.61% meant to represent?? The average per year was closer to 6.5% if that's what he meant.
(Edit- replaced the * by x and added an =)