The state is, even if you're found guilty. You just need to be in a position where you couldn't afford an attorney yourself.
That's...not really true. First, plaintiffs aren't generally liable for respondents costs in a civil suit if the plaintiff loses, so the idea that the fact that prosecuting authorities aren't responsible for defendants costs whenever the defendant is acquitted in a criminal case is unexpected given the civil parallel is bizarre.
Second, while it is possible to sue someone for abusing the system in a civil case (but just because they lost alone) and be awarded legal costs, the prevention of such abuse in the criminal system is generally provided by the early parts of the criminal process (indictment or preliminary hearing) where the the prosecution is required to demonstrate probable cause before being allowed to even proceed to trial at all.
I suppose you could make a case that a prosecution that fails to pass a preliminary hearing out to bear responsibility for the defendant's reasonable legal costs incurred to that point, and that that would be parallel to the kind of protections that exist in the civil system. You might even go farther and extend this by requiring a "preliminary hearing" reviewing the indictment even in cases where an indictment is required (where the defense would have assistance of counsel at the preliminary hearing), since in practice indictment has generally become a weaker protection than a preliminary hearing, even though its intended as a stronger protection against abuse (hence, why it is required for federal felonies.)
They were sure enough to seriously upset and damage a person's life when they pressed charges, and they better be willing to at least cover the cost of a defense when they're wrong.
In those rare instances where actual innocence are found, the jurisdiction does end up paying for the defendant's attorneys fees, and more, as a result of the civil lawsuit the defendant inevitably files.
If you're innocent until proven guilty, and they never prove you guilty....I'd call you innocent.
"Innocence" is a specific legal term which means that person is not only "not guilty" but further that there is sufficient proof that they did not commit the crime alleged.
I still think that's a better system though...
Of course, you could require that a) there's a fine for being caught at that and b) the department also has to pay for the appeal and initial case and prepay for any retrials.
Overall, I think it would be a large improvement, though.
Under the current system, a plea bargain is something like "Take 2 years in jail and pay $50-100k less or face 10 years in jail at trial, where you probably can't even afford a real defense."
Under the new system, a plea bargain would have to offer considerably more to the point it's obviously problematic, because acquitted defendants wouldn't still be out the money required to beat the system. Further, it's likely poor people will have better access to top notch lawyers if the lawyer can expect to recoup their cost from the state (rather than just not being paid by the poor person).
Also, presumably, the cost of good legal defense should be less than the $20,000 cost/year for incarceration.
Um, good? Marginal cases probably shouldn't be prosecuted unless there is a non-trivial public value to doing so.
I'm also a big fan of the fact that prosecutors should have no discretion in terms of jury makeup. If you can't make your case without stacking the deck, you should lose.
What's worse, that DAss offices are lacking in resources or that public defenders' offices are lacking in resources?
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/24/us/public-defenders-are-ti...
http://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/20...
Then there's all the underfunded PDs' offices for states/counties/cities that just don't have the resources to defend their clients.
Maybe a better system would involve both the prosecuting and defending attorneys be both paid for by the state from a pool of volunteers and both given the same compensation for their time?