Why argue oranges when I'm describing apples? (dividends)
If the broader market returns 10%, you can't say, "But I got a 3% dividend, that's apples to oranges." In the end it's all part of the total return.
I'm not arguing that dividends don't matter - on the contrary they matter a lot. But a stock with low total returns over time isn't saved just because the dividend portion of that is high.
2) You can make a judgment that in the future this will change. What's the basis of this, when most stock pickers are wrong as often as they are right?