> It just reduces the size of the crowd and shows a fundamental misunderstanding of statistics.
Why do you assume that what's in the NPR article is all there is to it, that there's no info, technical or other, left out?
Of course they thought of that, and checked. There's no regression to the mean, the elite group further improved, their estimates were 65 % better than the overall crowd.[0]
[0] http://www.economist.com/news/21589145-how-sort-best-rest-wh...