I try and keep things static unless I have really good reason to do dynamically generated markup. There are still very good reasons for having a backend sometimes.
There is a middle ground if you are primarily replacing a CMS though, which is using a static site generator like jekyll.
This is something I learnt while working at [1] DevelopmentSeed. They also built a wonderful editor for github pages called [2] Prose.
[1] http://developmentseed.org/blog/2012/07/27/build-cms-free-we... [2] http://prose.io