I remember when this study was first concluded and reported on. The CBC had a woman who participated in the study (maybe this very woman) on the program and it was so extremely obvious that her professional pride was wounded, and she really wanted to make herself feel better by telling the world that she really could pick out the Stradivarius.
I have no reason to doubt her; she's a professional violinist.
But it seems to me that the study was actually very effective at showing that masterwork violins do not necessarily sound better than modern violins, contrary to the regurgitated opinions of hundreds of thousands of novice violinists out there.