That's great! This means, of course, that the maximum utility schedule happened to lie in the subset of schedules satisfying both constraints, and you so there is no utility loss. The double-major in this case is just an added bonus of doing what you wanted to do, and I'm happy for people lucky enough to find themselves in that situation. From my time in college, though, I remember a number of people who were reasoning along the lines of "Well, I'm just three boring classes away from a double major... might as well pick it up I guess." For people in that situation, where they don't really want to take the extra three required classes, I'm arguing that the double major isn't worth the utility loss.
> Degree requirements exist because the degree committee (and accreditation organization) believe they have have a better sense of overall utility than most students.
Indeed, and good point: If you don't have a good sense of your utility function, then the decision to double major is roughly equivalent to using the implied utility function of the degree committee to help estimate your own utility. However in this case, I'd argue that you would probably get better results from asking a trusted professor or mentor for advice on classes to take, since the person you ask for advice would know you better than the degree committee.