In considering this, remember that the record might sometimes be deficient in ways that the court of appeals cannot identify on its own. And it seems likely that inadequate development will cause courts of appeals to things wrong as often as it permits them to get things right despite the procedural "technicality."
catch( DefenseDidNotDoSomethingImportantException e ){
Case.Retrial();
}
As a defendant (or coder), you don't want to have to rely on exception-handling to save you from error, but as a citizen, I'd like to prevent technicalities from blinding our judicial system to proper consideration of major issues. Technicalities are often there for a reason (as this one is), but that shouldn't stop us from getting at the heart of an issue.The opinion itself actually gets into all of this in considerable detail. I highly recommend reading pages 20-40 -- especially pages 22-23 -- if you find these issues interesting. The opinion also points out that there is a certain value in opinions' being final. If the court of appeals will just overlook the fact that parties have not raised all their arguments before the lower court, what incentive will litigants have in the future to do so? District courts are real courts! A litigant should not feel free to treat the district court proceeding lightly (as Lavabit seems to have done) in the hopes that it can prevail before the "real" court of appeals. The opinion also points out that the identification of issues of major public concern is probably not something that the court can be trusted to do objectively.
The judicial system is thus, in a sense, the very exception-handling system you want. It's catching exceptions called "Oh shit, we didn't think of this case and we need to decide consequences now".
(And vice versa, of course.)
Deleted comment
Remember that by the time a case reaches a court of appeals, with the government as a party, the U.S. itself must first decide its position is meritorious (it almost always has discretion to bring or defend a case). Then a district court also rules on it. So, for the district court to be reversed against the government, both the government lawyers and the district court must have been incorrect. This will not be an especially common occurrence even without the improper influence that you are insinuating. Given this posture, I find it remarkable, frankly, that the government loses appeals as frequently as it does. While it usually wins, it is hardly rare for them to lose.