I think this is the fundamental difference of opinion between people who think you can "cheat" in art, and people who don't.
I would argue that judging the quality of art based on the difficulty of producing it betrays a shallow appreciation of art. A person who says that is basically saying "I have no basis on which to judge this other than whether or not I could have produced it myself."
This is why you'll see a lot of overlap between people who sneer at "cheating" and people who dismiss things like modern art and found art as "not art".
In other words, the two groups are essentially using different definitions for the word "art".