What exactly is the problem being solved by having a standard deal which almost everybody gets?
What exactly is the problem being solved by having a standard deal which almost everybody gets?
Yes, one day you'll look at the cap table and say, "man it would be great to have that x% to give to employees" - but very likely you're company will be in a dramatically different place progress-wise and valuation-wise, so it's a major net-gain.
Companies come into YC with nothing but wireframes and companies come in with six digit revenues. Both will exit dramatically further along, hyper-focused, and with higher valuations (in my experience). Companies that are unicorns or growing like crazy or have crazy utility get even higher valuations, and it all works out pretty well.
IMO standard deal makes things incredible simple and easy on the front end, without the massive majority of potential pitfalls (signaling, jealousy, negotiating time, etc)
If starting a business is not at least somewhat about the money, why not just have everything a non-profit?
I've gotten told this very thing, only to have a business-minded company use it to make money on my hard work and effort (you should be happy you get to work on something you enjoy..for 1/2 market value and 50+ hours/week)
No one (I think) is suggesting that you start a business without the intention to make money.
Absolutely only start a business because you are driven to make something people want, customers & users love, and to create wealth for you, your partners/ shareholders/ stakeholders involved.
My point re YC is that decision should not be made by weighing the pro's and con's of the money and equity stake you will give up for it (vs other investors for example). The investment money is a tiny fraction of the total value/ resources that YC brings to the table.
Now, that may be a good thing, but it also might be a bad thing. At a certain point, this is a numbers game, and you want the market to sort things out, not YC management.
What was bad about the signaling problem with YCVC was that it probably often had nothing whatsoever to do with the value of the company, and was instead just an artifact of circumstance. But other investors might not be savvy enough (or just might not have the time to think through it) to understand that that was all that was happening.
It seems like they're planning to significantly decrease that variation. Almost all companies will give 7%, and a few exceptional cases might give less. This move eliminates all signaling risks (7% is now standard, so it's not a mark against companies, and any deviation is likely upwards).
(That's a big difference from the YC batch I went through back in Winter 2011)
Worked for Henry Ford.