Rust is showing that it's actually practical, in a somewhat-normal language with somewhat-normal libraries.
Two decades of garbage collected languages, with fat runtimes that does everything under the hood + lazy programmers with Moore's law mentality
Note: its ok for script languages that have exacly this purpose, to be easy and ask less from the programmer.. like Javascript or Lua.. But its a shame that languages like Java have created such a bad mentality..
For system programming its not cool to abstract the machine too much.. we've learned that lesson the hard way (see the big projects like hadoop in manage languages for an example)
Those languages asks almost nothing to use them.. but you end up paying a lot more latter, because of the abstractions layers you just cant change..
You are lucky if you project starts simple and remain simple over time, but the majority of the projects are not like that..
Yes: javascript for system programming like in nodejs is a bad idea (as in: "free entrance, pay with your blood later")
> For system programming its not cool to abstract the machine too much.. we've learned that lesson the hard way (see the big projects like hadoop in manage languages for an example)
Oh master, please do say what's wrong with Hadoop, one of the best and most successful pieces of open-source infrastructure. Truly you must know of a better alternative that isn't burdened with the cancer that is the JVM.
Also, you must mean something different when you're saying system programming, because in my dictionary, Hadoop ain't it. Not a native english speaker here, must take some lessons apparently.
Let me ask this diferently? how many Big mission-critical sucessfull projects you see that are not implemented in unmanaged languages like C/C++ ?? Browsers, OS, Databases , speech-libraries, Neural Nets ??
Hadoop happens to be in Java as Lucene and Sorl, because thats what Doug Cutting choose as his language,and this guy is a monster.. If Hadoop was created in something like C++, you can bet that it would have much more success than its having now (as you would probably be able to embedd even in smartphones)
Also java is almost there, because at least it has a type system.. but it started to popularize ideas from the Smalltalk, and Self, wich are good to be well known.. but nowadays, we have too many of them.. (and people seeing Rust ask for more of them?)
The problems that Rust are trying to solve, are very hard.. and we have enough choices for managed languages(java, c#, go, javascript, python, ruby).. but almost none for languages that do the core of our IT infrastructure like C/C++..
My comment was just to point out that there are a whole generation of programmers that were taught not to think about allocations, with everything automated for them.. its cool to have those tools around? of course, its nice to have choice! but not having any other options for much of what we do, and then when something cool like Rust shows up.. not being able to reconize it for what it is.. because you know.. you are expecting that any modern language must have a GC or not have generics or macros like some comments i have seen in this thread... its just plain nonsense..
Not only Rust can be used to those tasks, but also it take in consideration a lot of research in languages and type systems..
I was not saying those languages are bad per se (but used in wrong problem spaces not suited for them).. only that some developers are too much alienated and do not know what they are talking about well as their critiques shows..
edit: about Hadoop and system programming -> what is HDFS? distributed storage, distributed networks, consensus protocol, etc ? The layer that hadoop present to the platform user are definitly not system programming, but the lower levels of the platform wich is what hadoop is made of is
Give it time.
I am:
> I'd have thought that it is still too early to say,