The 1% of kids who did well in high school and then fail in college because they are so attached to their rote memorization of techniques have a profoundly broken approach to problem solving that is bigger than the education they received. I've tutored many kids exactly like that and it is very hard to pry them free of that mentality. It is part of their personality. Also, those kids were never really good at math in high school either and were battling (using tutors for help frequently) uphill to get through their entire primary curriculum.
The much bigger and real tragedy of math education in the US is the very large percentage of kids who have been labeled as "not good at math". Those kids 99% of the time are actually plenty good at math but have fallen out of the system because of frustration and a poor fit for their learning style. Those kids don't end up in universities trying to take calc for science majors at all because they believe they aren't capable and that is a crime.