"I know this is hard to believe, but Facebook really is a commodity product, and Friendster and Myspace have been doing it since years ago, and Diaspora is going to do the same thing, except be private and secure" - said someone everytime FB added a controversial feature.
There's definitely buy-in and momentum of established products...but sometimes, products in the same space can be differentiated in ways not directly related to their core. Github makes it substantially easier to share and collaborate. And that is why many people prefer it. If you reduce it to "Well other places have git, too"...then that's missing the point of why Github appeals to so many.