For people who are good in a certain area (running, piano, etc.) one thing that amazes me is how the average person does not realize exactly how good these people are at what they do. It is only after years of training yourself that you begin to realize how extraordinary the very best are. Someone a while ago created a series of large video screens that allowed people to race Ryan Hall (http://www.fastcodesign.com/1665449/video-screen-lets-you-ru...). The funny thing is that the average person cannot hold for 60 feet the pace that Ryan Hall can hold for 138,000 feet.
An ordinary person in any century does not have the genetic capability to run a sub 4:00 mile. There's very few that even have the potential. So the probability that out of the tiny fraction of people in the 18th century who did have this potential, one of them just happened to have the free time to train themselves to their genetic limit for this purpose? I doubt it.