Edit to add: That said, since Debian seems to be the main group willing to do any kind of binary distribution with Hurd, they get to call the shots.
Edit to add: That said, since Debian seems to be the main group willing to do any kind of binary distribution with Hurd, they get to call the shots.
Right now, the target audience are Hurd developers, who need a useful userspace to work with. Making that userspace as much like Linux as possible reduces the incremental maintenance effort, which is critically important given the limited number of developers.
(You could reasonably ask the value of developing Hurd at all, but given a set of people wanting to develop it, it makes sense for them to do so using a Debian userspace.)
I suppose that whoever uses it also needs userland software. It's fun to have a kernel with an unusual architecture, but less so when there is no application for it. I'm also not sure who the public is, apart from FSF people(?), kernel enthusiasts and people who like to experiment. But clearly there are enough people interested that it is getting more usable, and there is nothing wrong with that.
What I'm talking about is adopting things well outside the confines of POSIX, into using stuff like FHS and systemv-style init. Hurd has some powerful stuff that's more like Plan9 than it is like UNIX, and some linuxy ways of doing things can get in the way of using those.
The world gains very little from having a great OS nobody knows about.
With time, the Hurd-ish ways should prevail where it makes sense.
Really, the next innovation in kernels and system architecture needs to be an improvement on plan9 - not on Unix, again.
Hurd predates Linux, it isn't architecturally different from Linux, Linux is architecturally different from it - but almost none of the runtime cares if it is running on a modular monolithic kernel (Linux) or a microkernel (Hurd, Minix, Mach).
Back to your sentiment, yeah it makes sense for all things GNU to be able to work with each other. That's one of the biggest benefits of this Debian project.
Android's largely convinced me otherwise.
(Android isn't a Linux OS so far as I'm concerned).
I don't run linux, I run Debian. Debian might include packages from GNU, Linux, BSD, HURD, KDE, GNOME, US, EU, and X, but do I call the OS any of those?
Static operative systems with packages from only one source is a thing of the past.
According to whose techne?
This really all boils down to opinions, nothing else.
They don't make it "as much like Linux as possible". Although nobody except for rms uses that name, the OS is actually called GNU. And they're "just" replacing the kernels, not really building the separate OS.
While modern GNU (and related) userland is, indeed, has many strong ties to Linux, their first milestone is probably to get things working, so, I guess, getting rid of Linuxisms just isn't the priority.