50% is not arbitrary. If they have more than 50% they can pull off double spends at their discretion, if they have less than 50% there is some element of chance.
Moreover, it's possible that one of the other 52% colludes with GHash.IO and they have more than 50%.
So 51% would be terrible, but 48% is 1) dangerously close to it 2) bad in itself because it allows for double spending eventually with reasonable probability.