Couldn't they just run more servers?
Couldn't they just run more servers?
A miner can have 51% of the hashing power, but if the blocks he produces are not accepted by clients (i.e. people with wallets, merchants, and the like), his 51% hash power is completely useless. His blocks need to be recognized by the clients, and if the clients decide that they do not want centralized mining pools, and decide that they only accept blocks with a second cryptopuzzle in them, miners who fail to switch will produce blocks that are unrecognized and therefore useless.
Would you get effectively two kinds of BTC? (aka. a network partition?)
Practically, this could be implemented as blocks after block X must follow the new rule, blocks X and earlier must follow the old rule. Where X is sufficiently far in the future to allow for people to update.