http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/20/business/in-head-hunting-b...
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/20/business/in-head-hunting-b...
I was not asked silly questions like "how many golf balls could you fit in a school bus" or "how do you move a mountain 3 feet to the side". These are the types of questions he explicitly references in the article.
edit: I will also add that there are differences between eng and non-eng interviews. I'm not familiar with the non-eng process really.
But how many times did you ask this question without actually verifying that YOU could answer it? And what does that mean about your process for generating and grading interview questions? And why did it have to be the interviewee who told you?
Maybe interviewees should be more confident, but maybe interviewers should be a little less self-confident. This is a huge cultural problem for the industry, but it's right in our blind spot.
And we have to ask why there are less women in tech since it became dominated by erroneously self-confident, high-testosterone personalities who think that hiring people like themselves is a meritocracy?
How many times had I asked it? 50? I had a couple folks answer it like I thought it should be answered. He was the only who nailed it enough to catch the error too.
The reality is interview performance is very different than work performance. Interview questions test interviewing ability more than anything else.
Over time I've realized that the only reliable predictor of success is seeing people's work results first hand when they don't think they are interviewing. The danger is this too breeds issues of familiarity and lack of diversity, because one only hires from their narrow circle of the world.
This makes it very tough to make college hires. The only things I've seen that worked are "High enough" GPA (with "High enough" being higher on non-technical majors) and some sign that the student had to significantly multi-task (lots of extra curriculars, research, or working through school). Most 21 year olds don't have interview training, so it's a very bad way to pick them.