Hacker News Reader

This "your UI shouldn’t mimick [sic] the native style of the platform" advice reminds me of what we used to hear when using Java and Swing a decade ago.

It resulted in a bad user experience then, and I think that still holds true today. Swing apps never felt right on any platform, even when using a native theme. It's probably no different for apps built using Cordova, too.

View on HN

This advice sounds more like sour grapes disguised as best practices. I believe a similar excuse was trotted out with Swing ("Swing is it's own platform!"). Users didn't care, they hated the non-native, slow, accessibility-unfriendly Swing apps, which they perceived as bloated and low-quality largely due to the feel.

I can't help but chuckle at the fact that we're making literally the same mistakes we made eight years ago while claiming progress.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com