This is sort of a half truth. Comcast has increased some speeds a little bit. But most of those speed increases are lies.
For instance, Comcast claims it's moving to deliver 500mbps service ("half-gigabit") in this letter. You might assume this is meant to be comparable with Google Fiber and other local Fiber initiatives. It's not.
Google Fiber is $70/month. Most local gigabit providers are $50-$100/month. Comcast's "half fiber" is $400/month. (see http://www.comcast.com/505). Half the speed at 400+% higher cost.
This isn't competition, this is Comcast lying about availability. It lets them claim that they deliver fast service, but that "the market doesn't want it".
Example:
"The Justice Department has reached out to the companies as it investigates whether the cable-industry merger (CMCSA:US) is anticompetitive, said the people, who asked not to be named because the review isn’t public."
http://www.businessweek.com/news/2014-07-11/disney-cbs-said-...
Thanks to Goole Comcast started to do higher speed internet, it was shocking to me how customers were not interested in it but right after the Google offering the very same customers went totally mad and they suddenly needed faster internet. Who understands these very complicated matters anyways?!?!
Deleted comment
I mean, it is. They provide internet service, to consumers. They are by definition a consumer ISP.
You might as well say "Google is not a retailer for consumers". Except when they are (Google Shopping Express, Google Play Store, etc)
Not to mention the dozens of other, smaller groups who run ISP's pushing similar speeds, and make it their mainline business.
http://www.vermontel.com/internet https://epbfi.com/internet/ http://www.sumofiber.com/residential_internet https://www.highlandsfibernetwork.com/internet
> does the fact that OnePlus offers the OnePlusOne for $300 (to the few people who can get it) mean that the Galaxy S5, which has similar specs but costs twice as much, is unreasonably priced?
If Samsung had a monopoly on phone sales, so that you were required to purchase a Galaxy S5 (just as most people are required to by Comcast to get any modern internet whatsoever) then yes, it would be fair to say that the S5 is unreasonably priced when compared to a OnePlus.
But their not. Anyone can choose to not purchase a Galaxy S5, and still own a smartphone with a dataplan. You can't choose to not purchase Comcast and still have high speed internet (in most areas).
- -
If Comcast wants to keep their monopoly, they have to submit to regulation on prices and services. (Just like every other utility). If Comcast doesn't want to be regulated, all they have to do is give up their monopoly utility status.
It's fairly cut and dry. They can't have it both ways. They can't keep getting free government money as a utility, and then turn around and pretend to be a luxury good (like a Galaxy S5 is).
Talk is cheap. Start actually doing something. Either offer copper at prices that can compete or better yet, put your money where your mouth is. If Comcast is worried that Title II is going to decentatvie infrastructure spending, prove me wrong and actually build out a fiber infrastructure while Title II isn't a thing. Use some of that 7 billion[1] a year you see in the black and start building some real infrastructure instead of just sitting on copper for as long as you possibly can.
*When it's convenient. God only knows how oversold Comcast's service is.
This right here is a really good reason why Internet service needs to be Title II'd.
If the primary concern surrounding what is now an incredibly vital piece of the communications infrastructure is, 'how do we keep shareholders happy', then our priorities are fucked.
So it may be the most profitable part of Google's business, or it may earn as little as $0 profit, which is roughly what you'd expect in a perfectly competitive commodity market. In any case, we can clearly see that Comcast is not serving consumers as well as possible.
[1] This issue is important but underappreciated here on HN. Uptake rate is a key driver for the cost/benefit analysis of investing in telecom infrastructure. The cost of building out to a neighborhood dominates the cost term. So how many people in each neighborhood sign up has a huge impact on your per user cost. Google only builds out to fiberhoods with demonstrated interest. In most cities, Comcast is legally prevented from doing this.
(Lucy is buying a pound of steak from the butcher shop. Note this was set in the 1950's, so food is considerably cheaper than it is now)
Butcher: that will be $0.85, please
Lucy: $0.85!? Bob's Butcher down the street sells steak for $0.55 per pound!
Butcher: then go buy your steak from Bob's.
Lucy: I would, but Bob's is out of steak.
Butcher: Lady, when I'm out of steak, I'll sell it for $0.50 per pound!
For all but less than a handful of places, Google Fiber is Bob's Butcher.
They've certainly added higher tiers. I saw their 105mbps product was available in my neighborhood and called. The non-promotional price just for internet floats around $180 a month. That's a far cry from these municipal fiber shops that deliver that speed or higher AND television for less cost.
This is an easy way for ISPs to say to regulators, "Look we offered it but no one ordered it." Of course, no one wants to pay $180 for internet, especially when google fiber goes for $70 or so. I think their 400mbps product is around $400, which is insane.
No human being not under the employ of Comcast know what Comcast is doing "in the major metros". People who use Comcast only know of their little neck of the woods, so when you go out to do your astroturfing campaign you need to make sure that you appear to be a real human being by talking about a specific location which you personally have experience with.