* H is false
* H is true
When some actor A introduces new evidence in support of H, there are additional hypotheses that must be introduced: * H is false, and A is lying
* H is true, and A is telling the truth
* H is true, and A is lying
* H is false, and A is telling the truth
Any evidence that A introduces in support of H equally supports the first two new hypotheses, while any evidence that A introduces refuting H supports the last two. The result is that, depending on your priors on H and on A's trustworthiness, A's evidence might never be able to convince you that H is true. This means that logical fallacies such as the genetic fallacy are not applicable when there is expertise involved.If we were all experts or had unlimited time and access to the same information as an argument's proponents, then the genetic fallacy would be hugely useful. With real-world constraints on time and information, it's almost always impossible to evaluate an argument separately from its proponent's commitment to truth.
[1] http://omega.albany.edu:8008/ETJ-PDF/cc5d.pdf [2] Previous HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7929203