This sounds like it could be abused. If I'm rich enough, what's to stop me from running a bad ad for a candidate I don't like as a way to force them to donate all their money to charity?
This sounds like it could be abused. If I'm rich enough, what's to stop me from running a bad ad for a candidate I don't like as a way to force them to donate all their money to charity?
- Lawrence Lessig (Harvard, Creative Commons, MayDAY Pac) - Richard Painter (George W. Bush's ethics czar) - Buddy Roemer (former Governor of Louisiana, has been both a D and an R)
I have to say that while I know it's difficult to find people qualified for such a job who don't have huge political ties, it's disappointing to see such heavily biased people be on a committee to make decisions like that.
http://www.law.umn.edu/facultyprofiles/painterr.html http://wisconsinlawreview.org/wp-content/files/1-Nagy-Painte...
Buddy Roemer is also not an ideologue by any means.
Roemer has been a self-declared Republican for 23 years. Painter seems reasonable and thoughtful, but when making political judgements it's tough to overlook his connection to the Bush administration. Centrist and liberal observers can be forgiven for being suspicious of a committee with two Republicans and a techno-liberal.
I don't envy the people who had to organize this, by the way. Either you set up an odd-numbered panel and expect a bunch of criticism or you setup a even-numbered panel and prepare yourself for stalemates and ineffectiveness. (I suppose you could have a very large odd-numbered panel and hope that the law of averages helps you remain balanced.)