Whatever you choose, learn git along with it. It helps to answer the question, "This used to work, what did I do to break it?"
Also, call me sentimental but I learned C/C++ as my first language and would recommend it. I don't see a codeacademy class for that though, and it's not really perfect for web development.
If you find that codeacademy isn't working out, I've also personally used codeschool.com and had great experiences there.