A couple comments:
> Node doesn't follow SemVer, Rails doesn't do it, Python doesn't do it, Ruby doesn't do it, jQuery doesn't (really) do it
Node does (because it's <1.0.0 where semver's rules are different). Everything else you list is older than semver, so short of a time machine or a radical change to their long-established versioning policies, there's not much they can do.
> the responsible way is to set aside five or ten minutes, every once in a while, to go through and update your dependencies, and make any minor changes that need to be made at that time.
That works fine for your immediate dependencies. The reason why I think things like semver are important is that the above doesn't work at all with transitive dependencies.
If my app uses foo which uses bar which uses baz and the maintainers of baz decide to make a breaking change in a minor version, I'm not in a happy place when that wolf in sheep's clothing appears in my dependency graph. I'll see that my app is broken, but unless I want to fork bar and maybe foo and start mucking around in code I've never touched before, my options are pretty limited.
I don't think semver is perfect, but I find it does make transitive and shared dependencies a lot more reliable to work with. I'm willing to sacrifice human-meaningful version numbers to get that.