This makes sense on the surface, but the confounding factor is that the NYC MTA cards are rather flimsy. Bend these cards just a little bit and they sometimes don't scan as smoothly. The trivial inconvenience of social pressure while attempting to swipe an inconsistent card with a bunch of other people behind you waiting to push through the turnstiles is enough to cause me to consider purchasing a new card.
Yes, most of the time we're just refilling the same card over and over, but these cards also have an expiry date of 1 year. This is still a good hack to keep in mind.