That's not the claim being made, especially given it's compared to similarly-clocked SoC.
The article makes two claims: 1. the watch stutters which may be caused by the low floating-point performances (benched very low), and 2. the SoC is power-hungry leading to miserable battery life.
The difference? The other SoC are based on Cortex A7, which was created in part to provide equivalent performances but much better efficiency than the A8: http://images.anandtech.com/doci/4991/Screen%20Shot%202011-1...