It can be a very specific cut of meat. A less common herb (fresh). "Ethnic" spices. A distinct type of dairy (which can be simply something like whole milk. I rarely use this, and never buy it in a normal shopping trip), such as a unique type of cheese. A strange vegetable. A very specific oil (even something like peanut or sesame oil would be odd in a normal house, though the moment you open it the expiry clock starts ticking). Etc. And if I do buy them, I usually have to buy them in such a quantity that it makes the meal very expensive, because I know the end result is that I throw out 9/10ths of it, having used the small amount in the recipe.
I usually just skip the recipe, not trusting my judgment on potential substitutions. In the odd case I do pursue it, the shopping experience is usually time consuming and brutal, and very expensive, to make one meal.
There is a business, or at least social, model somewhere in this. e.g. a "menu club" where everyone works through the recipes of a Jamie Oliver book, ideally in a more sustainable manner -- e.g. everyone stops by a location with their own containers and takes the right quantity from the bulk and economically purchased ingredients, taking a little vial of peanut oil, an eggplant, three anchovies, and on and on.