Again, how he gets this from Amanda’s and my presentation is beyond
me
Yes, I don't doubt it is beyond him. Yet he is one of only two very smart people with very interesting things to say that managed to get themselves removed from my various feeds, because I just couldn't stand their idolatry of static-typing and never ending condescension of anything remotely critical of it anymore.I haven't seen the presentation, but I don't for a second doubt they implied that:
If somebody stays away from typed languages, it [means]
they’re stupid, or lack education, or are afraid of maths. There
are [no] valid practical reasons for staying away [from type
languages].
He believes they were being very constructive, showing an understanding for other opinions and taking a nuanced view of static typing, with an eye for valid criticisms. I know, from the online reviews, many did not experience the talk that way.