Using the second concept of "average," yes I do. I have seen lots of car accidents, and lots of people pulled over by police (presumably for speeding or reckless driving). I have never experienced either, other than being pulled over once for a missing tail light (humorously, literally hours after I had purchased that vehicle). So I do consider myself a better than average driver.
But this idea of "better than average driver" just isn't very useful. Because presumably the majority of drivers have not been in an accident, while the average number of accidents per driver is obviously greater than zero. Thus most people are better than average drivers, in the same sense that most people have more fingers than average.