Cursed be the people who articulate a vision and code it. Punish failure. Punish presumed failure. Presume all new ideas to be failure until they are widely adopted. Reserve the greatest wrath for those who give away their presumed failures.
I feel it's always important to reduce everyone's detailed objections to 'haterism' because, well, haters, right?
My problem is that the reply was a completely empty justification for anything, not that it was defending Poettering or systemd. The reason other people disagree with things that one agrees with is not because they are bitter, angry, hateful types who love to object (because they have never accomplished anything, and are secretly jealous, just like mom said.)
There can be legitimate critiques of systems, as you say. This was not.