>> "Nothing that represents industry consensus about how the structure of web content should mature so that it is accessible to the handicapped. Nothing that makes it easier to markup content with its semantics in an extensible way."
Yeah just a lot of "useful" "practical" stuff like Audio, Video tags, postMessage, web workers, canvas, etc etc
HTML5 is about improving the REAL world wide web. Not the imaginary 'wouldn't if be nice if we started again' web. I think they've done a great job with the features they've added.
XHTML failed because it had a small subset of the functionality available with HTML, and gave no real world advantages. It made people obsess over validation rather than what actually works in real world browsers.
>> "so he could form the World Wide Web Foundation (ironically, an organization that can't put up a web page that is valid!)."
Case in point. If it shows up nicely in real world browsers, who cares.
>> "I have great passion for the X in XHTML - extensibility."
I am the complete opposite. I believe you should use a solution tailored to the problem. Not some multipurpose open ended general purpose 'can do anything' solution. And guess what... Extensibility is simple X* just makes it look really hard.
XML, XHTML, XMPP - they are all ridiculously over engineered overly complex things. They're the opposite of an 'elegant' solution.
>> "I assume those 4 out of your ~400 members were saying "hey, we don't want to implement XML-based semantic web. It's haaaaaard (insert whine here)"."
No, I'd expect they were thinking to themselevs "Make something people want". Why the hell would anyone using a browser care if it's XML-based semantic over complexity. They were more likely thinking about adding features PEOPLE WANT. Like audio/video/canvas tags etc Why would they do a ton of work to support something that has less functionality :/