There may be hope that a drop in wheat production leads to a drop in mental health issues.
There may be hope that a drop in wheat production leads to a drop in mental health issues.
You might be interested to know that it wasn't that long ago that humans typically got up to 80% of their calories from wheat in the form of bread.
Today it's about 30-40% (in the US anyway).
So there ALREADY has been a huge drop in wheat production. If anything it might be time to reverse that, not extend it.
PS. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seitan is quite yummy, it's almost pure gluten and is a wonderful source of vegetarian protein.
http://authoritynutrition.com/modern-wheat-health-nightmare/
That article did not exactly strike me as very credible. It basically took every single possible thing it could find and included them, no matter how credible or not credible the source.
People will look for any excuse to justify their behavior. But really gluten is perfectly fine for 99% of people and saying "the wheat changed" does not change it.
Yes, the wheat did change, but the differences can hardly be enough to say "that's the cause of mental health issues".
That is, unless there are infra-clinical effects.
But from my personal circles and work ones I am seeing lots of people that have always been sensitive and prone to say they have some weird diseases are adopting this, switching to Gluten-free and using it like a brand.
I've been away from home for some time, I meet something like 10 people from a total of 100 maybe... that claimed to have some variation of Celiac disease, a few even told me that all their tests were negative, but tests don't matter they still had it. Most of those people didn't know each other.
Now I am back home and guess what? I am finding that the same kind of people around here are claiming the same thing.
Most of those people I meet at IT related things, sport activities and random day to day life
I fell people want to be special and sometimes they do it by having a special condition or something like that.
Besides the real ones we keep creating diseases that are really loose specified and releasing it to the public. People catch those things and blame all their problems on some super special condition.
I can't seat still, I really can't. And I talk a lot too... I've lived like that, learned to control it and to focus when needed. I am no Jedi, life thought me that this behavior would make my life miserable. Now a days children like me are sick! Wonderful, problem solved.
Maybe they really feel better on gluten-free diet ?
>>I fell people want to be special and sometimes they do it by having a special condition or something like that.
You are the worse kind of skeptic. People are telling you that they are feeling better/some conditions go away on gluten free diet and you not only don't believe them but you project some silly justification on them like "want to feel special".
>>I can't seat still, I really can't. And I talk a lot too... I've lived like that, learned to control it and to focus when needed.
It's easier to learn for some and more difficult for others. That you were able to learn on your own doesn't mean others can without pharmacological help. Also maybe some people other than you feel better on gluten free diet.
If a person feels better on a gluten-free diet, it does not necessarily mean they have a gluten sensitivity. For example, see this study of people who self-reported as having gluten sensitivity. The participants unanimously reported feeling better on the low-FODMAP run-in diet, but during the trials were found to have no specific reactions to gluten. This suggests that gluten was not actually responsible for their symptoms. One possible explanation is that a gluten-free diet may lead a person to also avoid (unintentionally) the actual cause of the symptoms (e.g. other FODMAPs that happen to be found alongside gluten in foods).
http://www.gastrojournal.org/article/S0016-5085(13)00702-6/f...
Being a skeptic practically requires that you ignore anything based on it.
(but, for instance, hives during an allergic reaction can be assessed by a third party, so they aren't the same as "I feel better.")
No. You really don't. Vague symptoms like bloating or specific pain come and go all the time. You might have some indication that it worked from your single experiment, but calling it "strong evidence" is just...
Imagine if I used your logic to come up with a cure for the common cold? I'd be shouting eureka after 6 days
I never argue with someone about it, or try to talk them out of it.I think that if they are happy like that. Fine for them. I am just stating facts and creating my opinion based on those experiences.
I think it's completely wrong to tell a child they have a disease for life and will have to take drugs because they run a lot or can't listen to 6 hours of class. Pharmaceutical companies must love those new diseases...
Whether or not it's all in the mind is kinda moot, as it still makes them feel bad. By doing something, anything, they feel a bit better.
The same person will go through all these things. And then change their mind without any comment.
But going through the motions still makes them feel better, so I'm saying, even though it's not pharmacologically effective, psychologically it is a kind of cure and you shouldn't just dismiss it. It helps them, so why criticize it? Unless it's dangerous of course.
You can believe in the actual science, but believe in the cure at the same time. It's the best of both worlds.
And I'm actually saying this from experience, I'm going through it at the moment. In reality I'm simply suffering from anxiety. But my brain keeps irrationally latching on to things, it wants something to point at and be scared of. I have had to stop googling any sensations I feel as my brain will just latch on to anything I read.
At the beginning it was actually very scary and disorientating.
Now I'm getting over the anxiety and understand it, I can laugh at it and it's becoming less frequent. But it still happens. Someone mentioned vitamin D deficiency here a few days ago. And now of course I have that. But my scientific brain can understand that it's the anxiety again, and I don't. But I do. In a week or two, rationality will win, simply by waiting for that anxiety to disappear.
Being actually able to do something, like cut gluten out, is in itself actually quite calming.
I am not against it. Just citing some facts I observed. Medical tests will tell you if you have Celiac disease or not. If you don't and want to keep doing it, fine!
I will not talk with you about it and will run from that topic in order to not offend you, but my opinion still is that this is some mind game people are playing with themselves (unconsiously)
Anyway, I am happy you are happy.
-tests doesn't cater for everything; maybe there is some mechanism in which gluten harms those people which isn't detected by tests
-maybe removing food with gluten from the diet removes something else which was harmful (one hypothesis is that maybe it's this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FODMAP)
Your attitude is amazingly closed minded. There is nothing wrong with being skeptical but suggesting all those people just want to feel special (or similar psychoanalytical mumbo-jumbo) is just made-up nonsense. There is 0 evidence that they do it to want to feel special or what not but there is a lot of evidence that they in fact feel better (their feedback).
Given what we know about people, this hypothesis is a priori far more plausible than gluten acting in some mysterious way that can't be identified, and somewhat more plausible than gluten being associated with other things that people are sensitive to.
The suggestion that gluten is bad in ways that can't be detected is made less plausible by generic blind testing. Put people self-identified gluten-sensitive people on blinded diets with and without gluten and see if there is a difference. This has been done, and the test is negative. This is a black-box test that is completely independent of the mechanism of action.
Look: http://www.realclearscience.com/blog/2014/05/gluten_sensitiv...
As that same study shows, the suggestion that gluten is associated with something else bad is not totally implausible, but anyone aware of the difficulty of teasing out confounding factors in nutritional research will tend to strongly discount any form of anecdotal self-report as unreliable, because self-report about a subject where people are known to very easily fool themselves simply does not increase the posterior plausibility of the hypothesis very much. The potential for confirmation and reporting bias is far too high.
This is not close-mindedness, but rather a realistic assessment of the situation based on the long history of dietary fads, all of which were strongly supported by self-report, and later turned out to be ineffective, sometimes dangerous, nonsense.
I never said all of the people.
I also said, that I felt that. The same way people feel better and we have no proof of it yet.
And I actually agree with you about some unknown side effects, but several of those people I've known have been shifting or adding the lasted new diseases/allergy and currently it looks like it's Celiac disease that is the trend.