I wish you comment were downvoted instead of karmakaze's one.

He is expressing an opinion and even if he is wrong, it is still an interesting idea, and shows some effort. A decent short explanation could show the mistake, and make a good comment->answer combo.

Instead you quoted a comment which is out of context ( Feynman's comment is intended for physicists of his level ), contributing nothing.

( Please don't take this as a personal attack ( it isn't), but more a thought what's wrong with HN in light of recent debate )