I hear statement (1) quite a lot, but it seems like a really subjective criterion. When I hear this, I think, "If I'm not as passionate as Feynman, I should not go to grad school." And so I haven't. Am I looking at this the wrong way? When I compare the subjects I enjoy and the careers that allow freedom and decent pay, physics seems to be the only thing that remains. Is that not enough? I don't have the confidence to know whether I'll love the subject in ten years. I also think anyone who has that confidence is either a Feynman-type or has deluded themselves. Regarding (2), don't most hard science grad programs pay the students?
I'm also not saying that computational physicists are more employable than common programmers (or that they're better software developers!). I'm just saying I enjoy working on problems similar to those encountered in computational physics. I enjoy figuring out how things work and modelling them. In case I ended up hating physics by the end of graduate school, at least I'd have a strong background in mathematics and programming, and those skills could be transferred to domains with similar problems.
If you don't mind me asking, are you still working in physics? Based on your "about" section, you seem to be interested in a great many things, like myself. Before entering graduate school, could you truly not think of doing anything else, i.e., did you truly obey criterion (1)? I can think of many things I'd still like to do while I'm young: start a business, write songs professionally, act... but it's hard to take risks like that when you've got a good (and more practical) thing going.