What am I missing about the accounting?
What am I missing about the accounting?
A company can be profitable and still have a negative valuation, specifically if its liabilities outgrow its revenue. Generally, such companies become takeover targets if there's anything worth preserving. (Theoretically, the concept is that equity holders will take a discount on their shares because the company's poor prospects reduce liquidity in trade, and holding onto a share is seen as riskier than taking a lesser haircut now.)
The previous discussion is at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7606891.
In the case of Yahoo, the market believes that it will destroy a substantial portion of the value of their share of the Alibaba business by making bad investments into core Yahoo.
Yes, theoretically it is. However, the value (price) of something is not decided by some formula, it's decided by the market.
Think back to the real estate crash of 2007. Value was dictated by what people would pay, not by some calculation of value.
If you take $1bn from alibaba -> $1BN goes to shareholders.
If yahoo takes $1bn from alibaba -> they pay a hundred million for a golden parachute, stagnate tumblr with the other 500$, buy startups for $499 million and return some loose change and pocket lint to investors.