Ex post facto is also explicitly forbidden by the US consitution (Article 1, sections 9, 10) [2], and by the UN's Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Article 11, section 2) [3].
On a technical level, you can argue that torture was already illegal under US law, however the torturers were advised by agents of the State that what they were doing was legal, so ex-post-facto could very reasonably apply. There may be people high up on the chain of command who can be prosecuted under US law, but for the most part prosecutions would have to go through international law.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuremberg_trials#cite_ref-reapp... [2] http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/charters/constitution_trans... [3] http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/
Ask yourself two questions:
Is it ok to kidnap someone, lock them in your basement, beat them and rape them?
Does some shit written on a piece of paper make it ok?
In this case, what was done is illegal under international law, and was illegal under international law at the time it was done, so people can be tried in international court without ex post facto concerns.
I am one of those people who disagree with the Nuremberg trials. If something atrocious happened, but was legal, then we should make it illegal and accept the fact that some people got away with doing horrible things.
Edit: I don't give a shit who is "right". My point is that any discussion that degrades this badly should not be here. Go somewhere else to discuss this stuff.
To compare this behaviour is not 'degrading' the conversation at all, on the contrary it's quite relevant to compare and contrast.
And that's exactly why it's off topic. It's politics.
A lot of times we disagree, but this is not one of them. If we're off in Nazi territory, there's no constructive conversation to be had.
I knew it'd be sensitive, but I had no idea.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530
You have the whole internet to talk about politics - do you really need to wreck this site with this stuff?
Also, haven't you people ever heard of Godwin's law?
EDIT: I think everyone on HN has heard of Godwin's Law. It's useful, but can also be a lazy way to quash meaningful discussion.
"Isn't this a lot like the Nuremberg defense?", for example.
As this article has already been upvoted over 200 times (implying some interest from hackers), trying to stifle further discussion is rather a lost cause.