I think you miss the point of religion if you think that's even on the table. Once you decide to take it literally, the preeminence of the supernatural by definition can't be questioned, it's a given. The only variable is the way reality can be reinterpreted to satisify dogma.
I think that religion can have a great deal of value as a cultural and mythological framework, but to me, wondering whether aliens suffer from original sin makes as much sense as wondering whether the Great Dragon eats their suns as well as ours each night.
Human religion is a human invention, and humans aren't even a rounding error at the scale of the universe. Billions and billions of stars and billions and billions of galaxies (as Carl Sagan apparently never said.) It's the height of arrogance to assume the superstitions of a few apes on an insignificant rock on an insignificant planet should mean anything to anyone but themselves.
> Human religion is a human invention
My personal belief is more along the lines of "Human religion is a human interpretation". I believe God exists and his reach is bigger than just our little planet here. However, I do not believe we are (yet) able to comprehend how everything fits together. I believe a correct understanding will require advances in both science and theology. Our current understanding is therefore very human centric because that's a limitation in our knowledge.
Assuming that there might be other gods on other worlds sounds rational, even reasonable. I think Voltaire(?) even wrote a short story about how human religions might look to aliens[0], although at the time, the prevalent interpretation was far more dogmatic than what the article describes.
But even working from the premise that there would even be a relationship between aliens and the Christian God to discover, to me, seems incredibly dogmatic.
[0] I thought it was called Mondomegas, but apparently, Google's never heard of it.
For a theologian, the existence of God is a defining premise in the same sense as the existence of an external universe governed by consistent laws discoverable through empirical processes is for scientist. As soon as you abandon the former premise, you are no longer operating as a theologian just as when you abandon the latter, you are no longer operating as a scientist.
> What's the point on logically arguing from a position of faith anyway? Doesn't that defeat the point?
No. The point of faith (in a general sense) is not to defy reason. Faith may contrast with empiricism, but the point at which they fundamentally diverge is not in the application of reason.
What point is that? On the contrary - it is necessary for certain "beliefs" be exempt from doubt in order for any logical discourse to be possible in the first place.
When historians are trying to reconcile contradictions in ancient texts in order to better understand history, it makes little sense (for most people) to say "I wonder if any of these historians will ever change the direction of their logic. It's funny that things like this are said 'How to reconcile those contradictions?", and not 'if contradictions exist, is it possible that none of it happened, and the entire universe along with everything in it appeared 5 minutes ago?' ".
It isn't too hard to imagine that some people think of religion and the existence of god in the same way as others do about - for example - philosophical realism. It seems to "defeat the point" only because your "point" is drastically different from that of those people.
I recommend reading Wittgenstein's On Certainty [1] for a much more sophisticated treatment of similar ideas.
[1] - http://www.amazon.com/On-Certainty-English-German-Edition/dp...
“To the philosophers of India, however, Relativity is no new discovery, just as the concept of light years is no matter for astonishment to people used to thinking of time in millions of kalpas, ( A kalpa is about 4,320,000 years). The fact that the wise men of India have not been concerned with technological applications of this knowledge arises from the circumstance that technology is but one of innumerable ways of applying it.”
0] http://ramanan50.wordpress.com/2014/05/11/hinduism-14-lokas-...