Unless I misunderstand the underlying argument, more skilled immigration is argued to be good because it is good for business. That's an economic argument, and I was making an economic argument in turn, that more skilled immigration may not straightforwardly result in a bigger talent pool in the US.
On the moral side, I do wonder if the West will be criticized in 50 years for its intellectual draining of the third world, not unlike the West's draining of colonies' natural resources 50 or 100 or more years ago. But this is a favorite thought experiment of mine, the question of "What currently fashionable thing will our grandchildren denounce us for doing?"
Anyway, you're disputing my assertion that "People choose careers for social reasons as well as for money. Adding a significant fraction of third world immigrants to a career lowers that career's prestige, meaning that talented natives who might have joined the field are less likely to, since they have options." First of all, I wish I had written that better in that I don't mean "a career", but rather "our career", ie, technology / programming. My mistake.
Still, doctors are a poor example since their supply is constrained by an outside force (medical education and licensing), and so their salaries are higher than they'd otherwise be, and their power is based on our awe for people who can save human life. In other words, they are nothing like programmers.
Also, I have heard that many governments like importing foreign doctors since in some cases this offloads parts of their education to their native land, and training doctors is expensive. Probably not the point you're looking for.
As for founders, I am not certain individual founders matter much in the cultural image of tech as a career. Most non-Californians can't name many founders, and certainly not many foreign born founders. I suspect that the only founders who get many people to consider tech to be a possible career are Jobs and Zuckerberg.
But as for programmers, people have various ideas floating around in their heads. They remember outsourcing, where American programmers ended up with no power and no money. This didn't do much for the prestige of the career. They think of nerds, obviously, who aren't too great on social norms. Does it seem reasonable that adding people to that labor market who are accustomed to lower living standards (wages), locked in by restrictive visas (power), and unfamiliar with American social norms (nerds) is actually going to make the field more attractive to natives?