If you want a good critique of HFS+, check one of John Siracusa's many rants[1].
Also, Gruber is not the author of Byword:
Even John Gruber of Daring Fireball and author of Byword…
If you want a good critique of HFS+, check one of John Siracusa's many rants[1].
Also, Gruber is not the author of Byword:
Even John Gruber of Daring Fireball and author of Byword…
So your Adobe example is flawed. They should be testing on case-sensitive volumes, but the vast majority of normal users don't want a file named README and readme in the same directory, and enforcing that invariant seems reasonable to me.
Which it does indeed, pretty badly. You would be hard pressed to find a worse FS still in use, excluding FAT, which will just never die.
Except the article doesn't contribute to the discussion and the quotes from Linus are unfortunately not newsworthy. Instead of a deep critique, perhaps pointing what it should learn from Btrfs and ZFS, he acuses Apple of not shipping a consumer case sensitive FS and criticizes its string and slash encoding, which although bad, are successfully abstracted even from most developers.
It then ends stating that Apple, like the weather, pays no attention to criticism. As empty an analysis as can be.