The US market is not well suited to selling phones retail. I don't see how Google can sell a smartphone that is considered "cheap" without being able to recoup anything in carrier subsidies. HTC smartphones retail for $400 and up without a subsidy. (For example, Google charges $400 for the developer version of the G1, but T-Mobile can sell it for $50 with a new contract)
Secondly, how is one phone going to work on Verizon and AT&T? Even if Google limits itself to GSM networks, AT&T and T-Mobile use different frequencies for 3G. Will they make an edition for each carrier?
I think Google is just creating one or more netbooks or "mobile internet devices" and this analyst (the only source in the story) got confused and thought it was a phone.