As an old guy in this industry, I may have a perspective here that many others lack in this discussion.
When Google acquired the dejanews archive, it was AWESOME! The search capability was exponentially better than what came before it. Google made a big production about this, including also of rhetoric about the importance of preserving the heritage of the Internet.
Then one day, mercurial Google released a competitor to Yahoo groups, and seeded it with the Usenet archives. Except that most every aspect of Google groups was worse than what came before. I gave up on the product a decade ago as my job role changed, but at that time thing like date searching were completely and utterly broken. Perhaps it's fixed now.
As people progress within Google, priorities will shift. So if you like some free offering without a monetization strategy (ie. Google Reader), you're likely to be disappointed. It's not evil, it is just life.
Librarians are a different lot. Preservation of knowledge is their thing. While the headline may be a little dramatic, it is accurate.