I don't know what soylent is (beyond just searching it in google). Wikipedia says:
Soylent is a nutritional drink, intended to cover all human nutritional requirements for an adult so that it may serve as main or sole food
There should be a very obvious test for this right? I think a large-scale controlled study would likely show negative effects compared to a randomly sampled population consuming the nutritional equivalent in natural products. This is actually part of the problem - you'll never read about such a study. Why? Because there is no profit incentive for anyone to finance a large-scale study that proves soylent or hypothetical product X to be useless or harmful.
If soylent (or company X) finances a study of their product and the results are contrary to their expectations (assuming the researches are honest and do not engage in fraud) - they can simply shelve that material - and if eventually study i++ is successful they can publish that (without ever referencing any number of past unpublished studies).
The FDA is wasting my money and yours (if you are a US citizen), in a way that normally should address this imbalance of selective interest in research. That it does not - hardly surprises me.
Yes, definitely, but I'm pretty sure it won't happen, and such a solution should not be allowed to make such claims ("intended to cover all human nutritional requirements for an adult") without any data supporting it, or at least a clear indication of the risks people take on it. In any case, some data is needed before you sell this kind of stuff to the public.
Products like Soylent or Plumpynut are foods, not drugs. Replacing one's entire diet with Soylent is logically equivalent to choosing to eat a banana rather than an apple with your lunch today.
If you have kwashiorkor or beriberi or scurvy or pellagra, it is unlikely that you could be effectively treated with Soylent, because it is formulated to satisfy daily needs, rather than to correct a deficiency that may have taken many months to manifest symptoms. It is designed to be a complete food, using a recipe.
And if you watched the movie (it doesn't hurt all that much), you would know that only Soylent Green was made from people, rather than algae, as was claimed. The Soylent company sold other types of food products, and everyone ate mostly Soylent-brand foods, because they could not afford anything better. In the film, all the extras got most of their nutrition from Soylent Orange or Soylent Blue, or whatever those grubby-looking flakes were in the bins. Soylent Green always sold out early, and was in short supply.
Still... not the best naming decision. Most people haven't seen any more of the movie than the scene where Heston cries "You've gotta tell 'em. Soylent Green is people!"
Define "nutritional equivalent" and "natural products"?
Do you just want the same levels of carbs/fat/protein as Soylent has, or do you want to also get the same levels of iron, sodium, vitamins, etc.? The more demanding you make that condition, the closer you get to just replicating Soylent. ("We could replace this artificial ingredient with that natural one, but the natural one has less salt, so to make up for that we have to...")
And it hardly seems fair to compare Soylent against a natural equivalent of Soylent, which doesn't currently exist to my knowledge, instead of against people's actual real-life diets.
And yes, pharma does lobby for laws to mandate vaccinations.
edit: obviously lobbying is not 100% responsible for all vaccinations laws, but it's partly so and increasing.
> edit: obviously lobbying is not 100% responsible for all vaccinations laws, but it's partly so and increasing
But how can you tell that the number of vaccination laws passed due to lobbying is increasing? Or possibly you just meant that lobbying dollars are increasing. But higher dollar values alone would tell us nothing about the relative success of that lobbying in getting laws passed. For example, perhaps the laws were going to be passed regardless, and the increased spend is illusory, being attributable to a general trend of increased lobbying spend in US big-business, inflation, or other factors. In an environment where lobbying is the norm, I think gauging the "effectiveness" of lobbying spend, especially for something which lots of people generally seem to support anyway, is a hard problem.
I just discussed this with my 81 year old father, who along with everyone else stood in line for the first polio vaccinations; that was the big fear for adults who'd survived the other things children are immunized for like measles, e.g. FDR lost almost all the use of his legs from it when he was 39 and counted himself lucky. I myself was born early enough that I got a lot of vaccinations as they first became available, and my parents, my mother a former RN, were very happy about this state of affairs.
Seriously, you might as well read Kippling's The Gods of the Copybook Headings in favor as anything else about this rank insanity. As well as gain a much more sympathetic view of the "less enlightened" of the world and history, as we arrogantly view them.
Deleted comment
Let me add that at least in theory, vaccines receive the strictest regulation of all drugs, since the they're given to ostensibly healthy people.
And if you want hard numbers to analyze the impact of lobbying, you're not going to get it, because lobbyists have lobbied against transparency laws. Anyhow, the impact is real such as with Merck and Gardasil. Further, it's not only laws that matter but court precedent and CDC policies.
But certainly you're right that many unbiased/disinterested people agree with pharma. It's definitely not an issue only related to profits.
Consider: Eating McDonalds could certainly be a prerequisite for admittance to McPreSchool, the worlds largest hypothetical private preschool system.
Consider also: your government operating as a corporation. Public health is a massive drain on government resources. Vaccines have VERY researched positive impact on public health. If government were a private corp then hell yes they would require vaccinations.
Except for double-blind placebo controlled trials, which are apparently unethical.
... in addition to the article here which casts doubt on all drug research.