Late night runs to a place called Taco John? Sounds like a post-alcohol food run. Maybe start there with the food waste issue :).
My girlfriend's son operates similarly; he often makes a box of macaroni and cheese for dinner, and only eats half of it. He refuses to eat left over macaroni, so regularly at least half the box is wasted. My suggestion would be to splits box in half prior to preparation, but so far that has yet to be impmemented.